Top Toilet Repair & Replacement Contractors in Columbus, Ohio Ranked

A functioning toilet is essential for any home or business, but issues like constant running, clogs, and leaks can disrupt your day and lead to higher water bills. Toilet repair and replacement services address these common problems, ensuring your bathroom fixtures operate efficiently and hygienically. This guide is designed to help Columbus residents understand their options, from simple fixes to full fixture replacements, and connect with skilled local professionals who can get the job done right.

Gunther Plumbing

3080 Scioto Darby Executive Ct, Hilliard, OH 43026

Gunther Plumbing is a family-owned plumbing company serving Columbus, OH, and surrounding suburbs. With over 20 years of experience, they offer a wide range of residential plumbing services including water heater installation and repair, sump pump maintenance, drain cleaning, sewer line repair, and hydro jetting. Their team uses camera inspection technology to accurately diagnose plumbing issues and provides certified backflow testing to ensure water safety. Gunther Plumbing is known for handling both routine maintenance and emergency repairs efficiently.

5.0

755 Reviews

Affordable Professional Plumbing

3840 Lacon Rd #21, Hilliard, OH 43026

Affordable Professional Plumbing is a small plumbing company based in Hilliard, OH, serving the Columbus, OH area. They specialize in residential and commercial plumbing services, including water heater installation, toilet repair, faucet replacement, and general plumbing repairs. With over a decade of experience, they handle plumbing repairs, replacements, and installations with a focus on thorough service. The company offers free estimates and emphasizes treating customers like friends. Affordable Professional Plumbing is equipped to repair or replace various plumbing components such as shower valves, water valves, and bathroom fixtures.

5.0

501 Reviews

The Local Plumber LLC

461 Industry Dr, Columbus, OH 43204

The Local Plumber LLC provides a wide range of residential and commercial plumbing services in Columbus, OH. Their expertise includes water heater installation and repair, drain cleaning, sewer line repair, leak detection, gas line installation, and toilet repair. They specialize in installing Navien brand tankless water heaters, offering energy-efficient solutions with on-demand hot water. Founded in 2022 by Trevor Randall, who has five years of professional plumbing experience in the Columbus area, the company emphasizes honest, hands-on service delivered by a small, dedicated team.

5.0

311 Reviews

Plumbing & Drain Professionals

374 Morrison Rd Suite A, Columbus, OH 43213

Plumbing & Drain Professionals is a locally owned plumbing company serving Columbus, OH. They provide a wide range of plumbing services including water heater repair and installation, drain cleaning, sewer line repair, leak detection, toilet repair, and hydro jetting. The company is equipped to handle both routine maintenance and emergency plumbing issues, with 24/7 availability for urgent needs. With decades of experience, they have expertise in managing plumbing systems in both older homes and new constructions.

4.9

509 Reviews

Rose Plumbing, LLC

6520 Oley Speaks Way suite a, Canal Winchester, OH 43110

Rose Plumbing, LLC is a family-owned plumbing company serving Columbus, OH, and surrounding areas. With over 30 years of experience, they provide a wide range of residential and commercial plumbing services including water heater repair and installation, drain cleaning, leak detection, repiping, gas line installation, toilet repair, and garbage disposal repair. Their certified professionals handle both emergency repairs and complete installations, offering 24/7 emergency commercial service to minimize downtime for businesses.

4.9

226 Reviews

See more providers in Columbus, OH

Common Toilet Problems in Columbus Homes

Residents in Columbus often encounter a few recurring toilet troubles. Understanding these issues is the first step toward a solution.

• A Running Toilet: This is one of the most frequent complaints and a major source of wasted water. The culprit is usually inside the tank-a worn-out flapper that doesn't seal properly or a faulty fill valve that doesn't shut off ¹. You might hear a constant refilling sound or see subtle movement in the bowl water.
• Persistent Clogs: While a plunger can handle minor blockages, recurring or severe clogs often indicate a deeper problem. This could be a partial obstruction further down the drain line or even in the main sewer line, requiring professional snaking equipment to clear ².
• Leaks at the Base: A toilet that feels loose or you notice water pooling around its base signals a broken seal. The wax ring that connects the toilet to the floor drain (the flange) can dry out, crack, or fail, allowing water to seep out with every flush ³. This requires prompt attention to prevent floor damage.
• Slow Filling Tank: After a flush, if the tank takes an unusually long time to refill, the issue is typically a clogged or failing fill valve. Sometimes, it can also be a problem with the household water supply valve not being fully open ¹.

Repair vs. Replacement: Making the Right Choice

When faced with a malfunctioning toilet, deciding whether to repair or replace it depends on the problem's nature, the toilet's age, and your long-term goals.

When Repair is the Best Path: Most common issues are repairable. Replacing internal components like the flapper, fill valve, or flush valve is a standard and cost-effective fix for running or weak-flushing toilets ². Similarly, resealing a leaky base with a new wax ring is a common repair that restores integrity. If the toilet is relatively new, matches your bathroom, and the bowl and tank are in good condition, repair is almost always the sensible choice.

Signs You Need a Full Toilet Replacement: There are times when installing a new fixture is more economical and beneficial than repeated repairs.

• Persistent Problems: If you are constantly dealing with clogs or leaks despite repairs, the toilet itself may have inherent design flaws or internal cracks.
• Age and Inefficiency: Older toilets, particularly those installed before 1994, use significantly more water per flush (often 3.5 to 7 gallons) compared to modern, WaterSense-labeled models that use just 1.28 gallons ⁴. Replacement can lead to substantial water savings.
• Visible Damage: Cracks in the porcelain, especially in the bowl, are a sanitation hazard and cannot be repaired. A wobbly toilet that can't be stabilized may indicate a broken floor flange that requires extensive work, during which replacement makes sense.
• Aesthetic or Comfort Upgrade: You may want to update the style of your bathroom, switch to an elongated bowl for comfort, or install a chair-height model for accessibility.

Understanding Repair and Replacement Costs

Costs for toilet services in Columbus vary based on the job's complexity, parts needed, and the service provider's labor rates. Getting a detailed quote from a professional is always recommended.

Typical Repair Costs:

• Simple Repairs: Fixing a running toilet by replacing a flapper or fill valve is generally the most affordable service, with average costs ranging from $100 to $250 ^{1 5}.
• Moderate Repairs: Addressing a leak at the base by replacing the wax ring and bolts, or clearing a stubborn internal clog, typically falls in the range of $150 to $400 ^{2 4}.
• Major Repairs: Fixing a broken pipe connection, replacing a damaged floor flange, or snaking a severe main line clog can cost between $300 and $600 or more, depending on the extent of the work ⁵.

Toilet Replacement Costs: The total cost for a new toilet installation includes both the price of the fixture and the labor to install it. A standard replacement, where the new toilet fits the existing plumbing footprint, typically has a labor cost between $300 and $800 ^{1 4}. The toilet unit itself can range from $100 for a basic model to over $1,000 for high-efficiency or designer styles. Additional costs arise if the plumbing needs to be moved or the floor flange requires repair.

Materials and Parts Involved

Whether for repair or replacement, professionals work with a standard set of components.

• Internal Tank Parts: These are typically made of plastic and rubber and include the flapper, fill valve, flush valve, and float. They are readily available and designed for DIY or professional replacement ^{1 3}.
• Seals and Hardware: The wax ring is a crucial seal made of wax and sometimes a rubber sleeve. Closet bolts and caps secure the toilet to the floor. Using a high-quality wax ring is key to preventing future leaks ³.
• Piping: Drain lines are usually PVC or ABS plastic. Supply lines are flexible braided stainless steel or chromed copper. These may need adjustment or replacement during an installation ⁶.
• The Fixture: Toilets themselves are vitreous china (ceramic) and come in one-piece or two-piece (tank and bowl separate) designs. Factors like bowl shape (round vs. elongated), height (standard vs. comfort), and flush technology (gravity vs. pressure-assisted) influence the choice ⁴.

Working with Columbus Plumbing Professionals

For reliable and lasting results, hiring a licensed plumber is advised. Local companies like Summers Plumbing Heating & Cooling and Plumbing Solutions serve the Columbus area with expertise in toilet services ^{7 8}. A professional brings diagnostic skills to correctly identify the root cause of a problem-distinguishing between a simple flapper issue and a more serious vent pipe blockage, for example. They also come equipped with specialized tools, like closet augers, flange repair kits, and heavy-duty lifters, that the average homeowner does not have. Perhaps most importantly, they ensure the work is done to code, which is critical for preventing leaks, maintaining proper drainage, and preserving your home's value. Labor rates in the area can vary, typically ranging from $85 to $230 per hour, so obtaining a few estimates is a wise approach ^{9 10}.

Frequently asked questions

Sources