Best Toilet Repair & Replacement Contractors in Ohio Ranked

A functioning toilet is essential for any Ohio home. When issues arise-from a simple running toilet to a major leak-they can lead to wasted water, higher utility bills, and potential water damage. Understanding your options for toilet repair or replacement helps you make an informed decision, whether you're tackling a DIY fix or seeking professional help. This guide outlines common problems, solutions, and considerations to help you find the right local service for your needs.

Gunther Plumbing

3080 Scioto Darby Executive Ct, Hilliard, OH 43026

Gunther Plumbing is a family-owned plumbing company serving Columbus, OH, and surrounding suburbs. With over 20 years of experience, they offer a wide range of residential plumbing services including water heater installation and repair, sump pump maintenance, drain cleaning, sewer line repair, and hydro jetting. Their team uses camera inspection technology to accurately diagnose plumbing issues and provides certified backflow testing to ensure water safety. Gunther Plumbing is known for handling both routine maintenance and emergency repairs efficiently.

5.0

755 Reviews

Affordable Professional Plumbing

3840 Lacon Rd #21, Hilliard, OH 43026

Affordable Professional Plumbing is a small plumbing company based in Hilliard, OH, serving the Columbus, OH area. They specialize in residential and commercial plumbing services, including water heater installation, toilet repair, faucet replacement, and general plumbing repairs. With over a decade of experience, they handle plumbing repairs, replacements, and installations with a focus on thorough service. The company offers free estimates and emphasizes treating customers like friends. Affordable Professional Plumbing is equipped to repair or replace various plumbing components such as shower valves, water valves, and bathroom fixtures.

5.0

501 Reviews

The Local Plumber LLC

461 Industry Dr, Columbus, OH 43204

The Local Plumber LLC provides a wide range of residential and commercial plumbing services in Columbus, OH. Their expertise includes water heater installation and repair, drain cleaning, sewer line repair, leak detection, gas line installation, and toilet repair. They specialize in installing Navien brand tankless water heaters, offering energy-efficient solutions with on-demand hot water. Founded in 2022 by Trevor Randall, who has five years of professional plumbing experience in the Columbus area, the company emphasizes honest, hands-on service delivered by a small, dedicated team.

5.0

311 Reviews

Triple Crown Plumbing

1226 Hands Pike, Covington, KY 41017

Triple Crown Plumbing is a family-owned plumbing company serving Cincinnati, OH, and the surrounding Northern Kentucky area. Led by Steele Hagan, a commercial master plumber with years of experience, the team offers a range of services including water heater repair and installation, sump pump repair, drain cleaning, gas line installation, and toilet repair. They are equipped to handle both residential and small business plumbing needs, with capabilities such as comprehensive plumbing repairs and water heater services. Triple Crown Plumbing is known for its community involvement and commitment to customer care.

5.0

274 Reviews

Roto-Rooter Plumbing & Water Cleanup

10574 Ravenna Rd Ste 2A, Twinsburg, OH 44087

Roto-Rooter Plumbing & Water Cleanup provides comprehensive residential and commercial plumbing services in Cleveland, OH. Their offerings include water heater repair and installation, drain cleaning, sewer line repair with trenchless options, leak detection, gas line installation, and garbage disposal repair. The company also specializes in emergency flood cleanup and mold remediation. They use advanced equipment such as hydro jetting for drain cleaning and offer 24/7 availability year-round to handle urgent plumbing needs. Serving the Cleveland area, Roto-Rooter has extensive experience managing complex commercial plumbing systems and residential repairs. Their expertise in trenchless sewer repair minimizes disruption during sewer line work. The company emphasizes prompt emergency response and continuous service availability, ensuring plumbing issues are addressed at any time.

5.0

224 Reviews

See more providers in Ohio

Common Toilet Problems in Ohio Homes

Residential toilets in Ohio frequently encounter a few specific issues. Recognizing the symptoms can help you diagnose the problem and decide on the next steps.

• Running Toilets: A toilet that runs constantly or intermittently is often the most common and wasteful issue. It's typically caused by a faulty flapper (the rubber seal at the bottom of the tank) or a malfunctioning fill valve (the mechanism that refills the tank after flushing) ^{1 2}. You might hear a hissing or trickling sound.
• Leaks at the Base: Water pooling around the base of your toilet is a serious sign. This usually indicates a failed wax ring, which seals the toilet to the drain flange on the floor ^{1 3}. A wobbly toilet often accompanies this problem.
• Persistent Clogs: While a plunger can handle minor blockages, frequent or severe clogs may point to a deeper issue in the drain line or a problem with the toilet's flush mechanics ^{2 4}.
• Weak or Incomplete Flush: If your toilet doesn't clear the bowl effectively, it could be due to low water level in the tank, a partially clogged rim jet, or issues with the fill valve ².

DIY Repairs vs. Professional Service

Many minor toilet troubles can be fixed with basic tools and replacement parts available at any Ohio home center ^{1 5 6}. Knowing when to DIY and when to call a pro can save you time, money, and prevent further damage.

When to Consider a DIY Fix

For homeowners who are comfortable with basic tools, some repairs are straightforward:

• Replacing a Flapper: If your toilet is running, a worn flapper is the likely culprit. This is a simple, sub-30-minute job. Turn off the water, flush to empty the tank, and swap the old flapper for a new one (cost: $10-$20) ^{1 2}.
• Adjusting or Replacing a Fill Valve: A faulty fill valve can cause running noises or weak flushes. Adjusting the float arm might solve it. If not, replacing the entire fill valve assembly is a common DIY project (part cost: $15-$30) ^{1 2}.
• Fixing a Loose Handle or Seat: These are simple bolt-on replacements that require no plumbing knowledge.

When to Call a Professional Plumber

Some situations require the expertise, tools, and warranty of a licensed Ohio plumber:

• Water Leaking from the Base: Repairing a failed wax ring or a broken toilet flange is labor-intensive. It involves removing the toilet, cleaning the old seal, and properly resetting it on a new, watertight seal. While parts are cheap ($10-$20), professional labor for a wax ring replacement typically ranges from $50 to $120+, and flange repair can cost $145-$165 or more ^{1 3 7}.
• A Cracked Porcelain Bowl or Tank: Cracks cannot be reliably repaired and pose a risk of sudden failure and flooding. Replacement is the only safe option ^{2 8 9}.
• Persistent or Severe Clogs: If a plunger or drain snake doesn't work, a professional has stronger augers and cameras to diagnose and clear blockages deep in the line.
• Complete Toilet Replacement: Installing a new toilet involves heavy lifting, proper sealing, and secure connection to the water supply and waste line. Professional installation ensures it's done correctly to prevent future leaks.

Cost Guide for Toilet Services in Ohio

Understanding potential costs helps you budget for repairs or replacement. Prices can vary based on the specific problem, toilet model, and labor rates in your part of Ohio.

• Professional Repair (Common Issues): For a standard service call to fix a running toilet by replacing a flapper or fill valve, homeowners can expect an average cost between $190 and $300 ^{1 5 10}. This includes parts, labor, and the service fee.
• Wax Ring or Flange Repair: As mentioned, this is more involved. Professional replacement of a wax ring typically costs between $50 and $200+, with price increasing if the underlying flange needs repair or replacement ^{1 7}.
• Complete Toilet Replacement: The total cost for installing a new toilet includes the price of the fixture itself plus installation labor. For a standard model with professional installation, the total project often falls in the range of $200 to $400 or more^{1 4 11}. This usually covers 1-2 hours of labor for removal, disposal of the old unit, and proper installation of the new one.

Signs You Need a New Toilet, Not a Repair

Sometimes, repeated repairs are a sign that replacement is a more economical and efficient long-term solution. Consider a new toilet if yours exhibits any of the following:

1. Age: Toilets manufactured before 1994 use 3.5 to 7 gallons per flush. Modern WaterSense® certified models use 1.28 gallons or less, offering significant water savings that can offset the cost of replacement over time ^{2 8}.
2. Frequent Repairs: If you're constantly fixing different components, the toilet is likely at the end of its service life.
3. Cracks in Porcelain: Any visible crack is a failure point waiting to happen and justifies immediate replacement ⁹.
4. Persistent Clogs or Inefficient Flushing: Older designs may simply lack the flushing power of newer, more efficient models.
5. Comfort and Fit: An opportunity to upgrade to a comfort-height (chair-height) model or a different style that better suits your bathroom.

Finding the Right Parts in Ohio

For DIY repairs, parts are widely accessible:

• Home Centers: Stores like Home Depot and Lowe's throughout Ohio carry universal flappers, fill valves, wax rings, and complete repair kits ^{1 5 6}.
• Online Retailers: A vast selection of parts for specific and older models can be found online.
• Plumbing Supply Stores: For specialty parts, such as those for pressure-assisted or one-piece toilets, a dedicated plumbing supplier may be necessary ⁶.

Frequently asked questions

Sources