Best Toilet Repair & Replacement Contractors in Pennsylvania Ranked

A malfunctioning toilet is more than an inconvenience; it can lead to wasted water, higher utility bills, and potential water damage in your Pennsylvania home. Understanding common toilet problems and their solutions helps you make informed decisions, whether you're tackling a simple DIY fix or seeking professional help. This guide provides a clear overview of toilet repair and replacement in PA, including typical issues, costs, and how to connect with qualified local specialists for reliable service.

Scarpignato Plumbing & Heating, LLC

507 Hastings Ave, Wallingford, PA 19086

Scarpignato Plumbing & Heating, LLC is a family-owned plumbing and heating company serving Philadelphia, PA, and nearby Delaware County communities since 2000. They offer a wide range of services including sewer camera inspections, water heater installation and repair, drain cleaning, hydro jetting, trenchless sewer repair, leak detection, repiping, gas line installation, and general plumbing maintenance. The company uses advanced equipment such as video camera inspection tools and trenchless pipe repair technology to handle complex plumbing issues efficiently. Owner Michael Scarpignato is a licensed master plumber with over 25 years of experience, ensuring expert service and multiple repair options tailored to customer needs. Emergency plumbing services are also available for urgent situations.

5.0

212 Reviews

P&A Plumbing & Drain Cleaning

520 Bloomfield Ave, Drexel Hill, PA 19026

P&A Plumbing & Drain Cleaning is a family-owned plumbing company serving Philadelphia, PA, and surrounding counties including Delaware, Montgomery, and Chester. With over 20 years of experience, their licensed master plumbers provide a wide range of services for residential and commercial clients. They specialize in water heater installation and repair, drain cleaning, sewer line repair, gas line installation, and leak detection. The company uses advanced techniques such as hydro jetting for clearing drains and offers 24/7 emergency plumbing services to address urgent issues promptly.

5.0

202 Reviews

A&S Drain Cleaning

165 Crabtree Dr, Levittown, PA 19055

A&S Drain Cleaning is a drainage service expert based near Philadelphia, PA, with over 30 years of experience. They specialize in drain cleaning, camera scoping, toilet and fixture replacement, and garbage disposal installation and repair. Their camera inspection technology helps diagnose plumbing issues precisely, minimizing invasive repairs. As a third-generation plumbing business, A&S Drain Cleaning focuses on maintaining pipe functionality without unnecessary excavation or replacements.

5.0

196 Reviews

Air Temp Solutions - AC Repair, Heating Repair, Water Heater Repair & Plumbing Devon PA

philadelphia

Air Temp Solutions - AC Repair, Heating Repair, Water Heater Repair & Plumbing Devon PA provides a wide range of plumbing and HVAC services in Philadelphia, PA. Their offerings include water heater installation and repair, tankless water heater services, water softener installation, sump pump repair, drain cleaning, hydro jetting, sewer line repair including trenchless methods, leak detection, repiping, gas line installation, and toilet repair. They also specialize in advanced sewer services such as video inspections and rooter services to diagnose and clear blockages efficiently. The company serves Philadelphia and nearby areas with comprehensive solutions for both routine maintenance and emergency repairs. Air Temp Solutions combines plumbing expertise with heating and cooling services, handling everything from furnace and boiler repairs to geothermal and mini-split system installations. Their team uses modern technology for leak detection and sewer inspections, and they offer trenchless sewer repairs that minimize property disruption. While the business history is not specified, their service range and technical capabilities reflect a broad skill set in residential plumbing and HVAC systems.

5.0

177 Reviews

MVP Plumbing Repair, Water Filtration & Softeners

3703 West Chester Pike, Newtown Square, PA 19073

MVP Plumbing Repair, Water Filtration & Softeners is a plumbing company serving Philadelphia, PA, and nearby areas including Delaware, Montgomery, and Chester Counties. They provide a range of plumbing services such as water heater repair and installation, water softener installation, drain cleaning, leak detection, repiping, and toilet repair. The company also specializes in installing whole-home water filtration systems tailored to specific water quality needs. MVP Plumbing emphasizes personalized service and clear communication, offering upfront pricing and detailed explanations of plumbing issues and solutions. They have experience installing many systems in the local area and focus on delivering solutions that fit individual needs and budgets.

5.0

173 Reviews

See more providers in Pennsylvania

Common Toilet Problems in Pennsylvania Homes

Toilets are robust fixtures, but several components can fail over time. Recognizing the symptoms can help you diagnose the issue.

• A Running Toilet: This is one of the most frequent problems and a major source of water waste. The sound of water constantly refilling the tank usually points to a faulty flapper (the rubber seal at the tank's bottom) that isn't sealing properly, or a malfunctioning fill valve and float assembly that doesn't shut off ^{1 2}. A worn flapper or an improperly adjusted float are common culprits.
• A Clogged Toilet: While a plunger often resolves minor clogs, persistent or severe blockages may require a closet auger (a specialized toilet snake) to reach deeper into the drain ^{1 3}. If a plunger and auger fail, the clog may be deeper in the drain line, necessitating professional equipment.
• Leaking at the Base: Water pooling around the toilet's base signals a broken seal. This typically means the wax ring that seals the toilet to the floor drain (the flange) has failed ^{1 3}. This repair requires removing the entire toilet, which is often best left to a professional to ensure a proper, leak-free seal and to inspect the flange for damage.
• Weak Flush or No Water in Bowl: This can be caused by a low water level in the tank (adjust the float), a clogged rim feed hole, or a problem with the flush valve ^{3 4}. Mineral deposits from hard water, common in parts of Pennsylvania, can block the small holes under the bowl's rim.

DIY Repairs vs. Professional Service

Knowing when to handle a repair yourself and when to call a plumber can save you time, money, and prevent further damage.

When DIY May Be Suitable:

• Replacing a flapper or fill valve: These are common, inexpensive parts readily available at any Pennsylvania home center. The process is generally straightforward with basic tools ^{1 5}.
• Adjusting the float or chain: If the toilet runs intermittently, the chain might be tangled or the float may need a simple adjustment.
• Tightening loose mounting bolts or a wobbly seat: These are simple mechanical fixes.

When to Call a Professional Plumber:

• Any leak from the base of the toilet. A failed wax ring can cause significant subfloor damage over time ^{3 4}.
• A persistent clog that a plunger and closet auger cannot clear.
• A cracked toilet tank or bowl. This requires immediate replacement.
• Replacing the entire toilet, including proper disposal of the old unit and ensuring the new one is correctly sealed and secured.
• If you suspect a damaged flange (the pipe fitting on the floor). Repairing or replacing a flange is a more complex task.

Understanding Repair and Replacement Costs

Costs for toilet services in Pennsylvania generally align with national averages, with the final price depending on the problem's complexity, the cost of parts, and the plumber's labor rates ^{6 7}.

Parts Costs: Replacement parts are typically inexpensive and available at local hardware stores and home centers like Home Depot or Lowe's throughout PA ¹.

• Flapper, handle, or chain: $5 - $20
• Fill valve assembly: $10 - $30
• Wax ring seal: $2 - $10

Professional Labor Costs: Labor is the primary driver of repair costs. Most plumbers charge a minimum service fee plus an hourly rate.

• Simple repairs (replacing a flapper or fill valve): $100 - $200 total (including parts and labor) ^{1 8 7}.
• Replacing a wax ring/seal: $150 - $300. The higher cost reflects the labor involved in safely removing and resetting the toilet ^{1 7 9}.
• Professional clog removal: $150 - $400+ for severe blockages requiring specialized equipment ^{8 7}.
• Complete toilet replacement: $300 - $1,000+. This wide range accounts for the price of the new toilet unit ($100-$500+) plus 1-3 hours of professional installation labor ^{8 10 9}.

Key Takeaway: While parts are cheap, the labor for tasks like removing the toilet to replace a wax ring or clearing a severe clog drives up the total cost significantly ^{6 10}. Getting quotes from local Pennsylvania plumbers is the best way to understand your specific project cost.

The Toilet Replacement Process

If your toilet is old, inefficient, cracked, or requires a costly repair, replacement may be the wiser choice. Modern toilets are significantly more water-efficient, which can lower your water bill.

1. Choosing a New Toilet: Consider height (standard or comfort height), bowl shape (elongated or round), flushing technology (gravity-fed or pressure-assisted), and water usage (1.28 gallons per flush is standard for WaterSense models).
2. Professional Installation: A plumber will shut off the water, disconnect the supply line, remove the old toilet, clean the flange area, install a new wax ring, set and secure the new toilet, reconnect the water supply, and check for leaks. They will also properly dispose of your old fixture.
3. Potential Complications: An installer may discover a cracked or improperly positioned flange, which will need repair before the new toilet can be installed, adding to the project's time and cost.

Maintaining Your Toilet

Preventative maintenance can extend the life of your toilet and avoid emergencies.

• Avoid flushing anything other than toilet paper and human waste. "Flushable" wipes, feminine hygiene products, and paper towels are common clog culprits.
• Clean your toilet regularly with non-abrasive cleaners to prevent mineral buildup in the rim holes and jet.
• Listen for running water and address it promptly to save water and money.
• Periodically check for slight movement or moisture at the toilet's base to catch a failing wax ring early.

Frequently asked questions

Sources