Top Toilet Repair & Replacement Contractors in New York, New York Ranked

A malfunctioning toilet is more than a nuisance; it's a disruption to your daily routine and can lead to wasted water, higher bills, and potential water damage. Whether you're dealing with a constantly running toilet, a persistent leak, or an outdated fixture, professional toilet repair and replacement services are essential for maintaining a functional and efficient bathroom. This guide provides a detailed look at common toilet problems, solutions, and what to expect when seeking a qualified professional in New York City to handle your toilet installation, fix, or maintenance needs.

Above and Beyond Plumbing and Heating LLC

5 Van Winkle Rd, Pine Brook, NJ 07058

Above and Beyond Plumbing and Heating LLC is a plumbing and heating service provider based in New York, NY. They offer a wide range of services including water heater repair and installation, water softener installation, drain cleaning, sewer line repair, leak detection, repiping, gas line installation, toilet repair, and garbage disposal repair. The company is known for its 24-hour emergency plumbing services, ensuring help is available whenever needed. They also specialize in boiler installation and repair, and install water filtration and softening systems to improve water quality. With over a decade of experience, Above and Beyond Plumbing and Heating LLC serves New York and surrounding areas, providing tailored solutions to meet specific plumbing and heating needs.

5.0

668 Reviews

No.1 Sewer & Drain Cleaning Services

1420 Ocean Pkwy #2b, Brooklyn, NY 11230

No.1 Sewer & Drain Cleaning Services provides drain cleaning and toilet repair in New York, NY. They handle clogged drains and sewer pipelines, including main sewer lines, yard drains, bathroom and kitchen sinks, toilets, and more. Their team can clear blockages caused by roots, grease, hair, and other debris. The company serves Brooklyn, Queens, Manhattan, Staten Island, and the Bronx. They offer emergency service and accept credit and debit card payments.

5.0

402 Reviews

Angler Plumbing, Heating & Drain Cleaning LLC

598 Hickory Ave, Saddle Brook, NJ 07663

Angler Plumbing, Heating & Drain Cleaning LLC is a family- and veteran-owned business serving New York, NY, and Bergen County, NJ. They provide a wide range of plumbing, heating, and drain services including water heater installation and repair, sump pump maintenance, gas line installation, and drain cleaning. Their licensed master plumber offers a one-year warranty on parts, labor, and materials, and the company is known for its safety-first approach and fully stocked trucks. With over 22 years of experience, Angler Plumbing also offers emergency services with weekend and evening appointments available upon request.

5.0

205 Reviews

Superior Plumbing, Heating, & Mechanical, LLC

new york

Superior Plumbing, Heating, & Mechanical, LLC is a family-owned business serving New York, NY, and surrounding areas including the five boroughs, Long Island, and Westchester County. Since 2003, they have provided commercial plumbing, heating, and mechanical services to building owners, managers, and engineers. Their licensed team offers a range of services such as drain cleaning, leak detection, gas line installation, toilet repair, backflow prevention, and water leak detection. They are certified for gas piping and backflow testing and provide 24/7 emergency and scheduled maintenance services to ensure building systems operate efficiently and comply with local codes.

5.0

142 Reviews

A&E NYC Plumbing

40 Fulton St, New York, NY 10038

A&E NYC Plumbing offers a wide range of plumbing services in New York, NY, including water heater repair and installation, drain cleaning, sewer line repair, leak detection, and gas line installation. They also handle faucet and toilet repairs, garbage disposal maintenance, and repiping projects. The company is licensed and insured, providing both residential and commercial plumbing solutions with a focus on safety and technical expertise. Their team is experienced in managing complex plumbing systems and offers free onsite estimates for more involved jobs.

5.0

134 Reviews

See more providers in New York, NY

Common Toilet Problems in NYC Homes

New York City's unique building stock, from historic pre-war apartments to modern high-rises, presents a variety of common toilet issues. Understanding these problems is the first step toward a solution.

• A Running Toilet: This is one of the most frequent complaints and a major source of water waste. The sound of water continuously flowing into the bowl or tank usually points to internal component failure. The culprits are often a worn-out flapper that no longer seals properly, a faulty fill valve that doesn't shut off, or a damaged flush valve ^{1 2}. These parts, typically made of rubber or plastic, degrade over time and need replacement.
• Leaks at the Toilet Base: Discovering water pooling around the base of your toilet is a clear sign of a leak. The most common cause is a failed wax ring seal between the toilet horn and the drain flange in the floor ^{1 3}. This seal can dry out, crack, or become misaligned. Repairing this requires removing the toilet, scraping away the old seal, and installing a new wax or modern rubber/foam gasket.
• Stubborn Clogs: While a plunger can handle minor blockages, recurrent or severe clogs may indicate a deeper problem in the toilet's trap or the drain line itself. Professional plumbers use augers (snakes) or hydro-jetting to clear obstructions. In older NYC buildings, persistent clogs might signal issues with cast iron or galvanized pipes that have narrowed due to corrosion ⁴.
• Weak Flush or No Water in Tank: If your toilet isn't refilling after a flush or has a weak flush, the issue could be with the water supply line, the fill valve, or a problem with the home's water pressure. A plumber will diagnose whether a component needs repair or if there's a supply line obstruction.

The Toilet Repair Process: From Diagnosis to Fix

When you contact a professional for toilet services, they will typically follow a systematic process to ensure a correct and lasting repair.

1. Inspection and Diagnosis: The plumber will first ask about the symptoms and then perform a visual and mechanical inspection. This may include checking for leaks with dye tablets, inspecting internal tank components, and assessing the toilet's stability on the floor.
2. Parts Identification: Based on the diagnosis, they will identify the necessary replacement parts. Common repair items include flappers, fill valve assemblies, flush valves, trip levers, and wax rings. In New York, professionals carry a range of parts compatible with various toilet brands and the specific plumbing standards found in local buildings ⁵.
3. The Repair or Replacement: For simple fixes like swapping a flapper, the work is often quick. For a wax ring replacement, the process is more involved: the water supply is shut off, the toilet is emptied and carefully lifted from the floor, the old seal is removed, and a new one is set before the toilet is reseated and reconnected ^{3 6}. All connections are tested thoroughly for leaks.

When to Consider Toilet Replacement Instead of Repair

While repair is often the most cost-effective route, there are times when a full toilet replacement is the smarter long-term investment.

• Age and Inefficiency: Older toilets, particularly those installed before 1994, can use 3.5 to 7 gallons per flush. Replacing them with a WaterSense-labeled high-efficiency model (using 1.28 gallons or less) can significantly reduce your household water consumption ^{2 6}.
• Frequent Repairs: If you find yourself constantly fixing different issues with the same toilet, the cumulative cost may approach or exceed that of a new, reliable unit.
• Cracks in Porcelain: Any visible crack in the toilet bowl or tank is a failure point that can lead to sudden leaking and water damage. Replacement is the only safe option.
• Outdated Style or Comfort: Upgrading to a new toilet can also be a functional and aesthetic home improvement, with options for elongated bowls for comfort, chair-height models for accessibility, and modern, easy-to-clean designs.

Materials and Components for Toilet Work

The longevity of a toilet repair or installation depends heavily on the quality of materials used. NYC professionals utilize a range of durable components.

• Internal Mechanics: Repair kits typically include plastic or brass fill valves, rubber or vinyl flappers, and plastic floats. For a more durable repair, some plumbers may recommend brass-bolstered components ⁵.
• Seals and Gaskets: The traditional wax ring is the standard for creating a watertight seal at the floor. Modern alternatives include wax-free rubber or foam gaskets, which can be easier for DIYers or in situations where adjustments might be needed.
• Supply Lines: The flexible hose connecting the toilet's fill valve to the wall shut-off valve is critical. Braided stainless steel lines are preferred for their strength and burst resistance compared to older plastic or copper lines ⁵.
• The Toilet Itself: New toilets are primarily vitreous china (porcelain). Key choices include one-piece vs. two-piece designs, round-front vs. elongated bowls, and gravity-flush vs. pressure-assisted flush systems. For NYC apartments, ensuring the rough-in measurement (the distance from the wall to the floor drain) is correct is crucial ³.

Understanding Costs for Toilet Services in New York

Costs for toilet repair and replacement in NYC can vary widely based on the problem, the parts required, the plumber's rates, and the specifics of your building.

• Labor Rates: Licensed master plumbers in New York City typically charge between $150 and $250 or more per hour for labor ^{1 7 8}. After-hours, weekend, or emergency calls usually incur a higher premium.
• Common Repair Costs:
  • Minor Repairs (Flapper, Fill Valve): $150 - $300 total, including parts and labor ^{1 6}.
  • Wax Ring/Leak Repair: $200 - $400+, as it is more labor-intensive ^{1 6}.
  • Clog Clearing: Prices vary but can start around the service call fee plus hourly labor if simple. Major drain line clearing costs more.
• Toilet Replacement Cost: This includes removal of the old fixture, disposal, and installation of the new toilet. For a standard model, installation labor typically ranges from $250 to $500. The total project cost, including the price of the new toilet itself, can range from $500 for a basic swap to $1,000 or more for a premium or smart toilet and complex installation ^{2 3 8}.
• Factors Influencing Price: The age of your building can impact cost. Pre-war buildings may have outdated plumbing, corroded bolts, or uneven floors that complicate the job. The need for a new supply line, flange repair, or shut-off valve replacement will also add to the final price ^{7 8}.

Choosing the Right Professional in NYC

Given the complexity and potential for water damage, selecting a qualified professional is paramount. Look for a licensed and insured master plumber with specific experience in New York City's diverse plumbing systems. They should be able to provide a clear, upfront estimate after a diagnosis, explain the necessary work in detail, and offer a warranty on both parts and labor. Checking reviews and asking for references can provide peace of mind that your toilet repair or new installation will be handled correctly and efficiently.

Frequently asked questions

Sources