Top Toilet Repair & Replacement Contractors in St Louis, Missouri Ranked

A functioning toilet is essential for any St. Louis home, but issues from simple leaks to complete failures can disrupt daily life and lead to costly water damage. Toilet repair and replacement services address everything from internal component failures to full fixture upgrades, ensuring your bathroom operates efficiently and hygienically. This guide helps you understand common problems, typical solutions, and local considerations, empowering you to make informed decisions when you need professional assistance.

Polar Plumbing, Heating & Air Conditioning

2227 Vandalia St, Collinsville, IL 62234

Polar Plumbing, Heating & Air Conditioning serves the St Louis, MO area with a wide range of plumbing and HVAC services. Their offerings include water heater repair and installation, sump pump and sewer line repair, leak detection, gas line installation, toilet repair, and garbage disposal repair. The company is known for handling urgent issues promptly, including emergency sump pump repairs and same-day water heater services. They also provide 24/7 emergency support for heating and cooling problems. Polar Plumbing has built a reputation for thorough and professional work, backed by a team that communicates clearly and respects customers' homes.

5.0

509 Reviews

CLEANSTREAM LLC

Monterey Dr, O'Fallon, IL 62269

CLEANSTREAM LLC is a plumbing and HVAC service provider located in St Louis, MO. They offer a wide range of services including drain cleaning, sewer camera inspections, hydro jetting, water heater repair and installation, leak detection, toilet repair, and water softener installation. Their capabilities include detailed video camera inspections and sewer and drain hydro-jetting to clear blockages effectively. CLEANSTREAM LLC also provides heating and cooling services such as air conditioner and furnace repair and replacement. The company offers 24/7 professional service and serves multiple nearby communities including O'Fallon, Belleville, and Collinsville.

5.0

202 Reviews

Polar Plumbing, Heating & Air Conditioning

131 Lincoln Pl Ct # 402, Belleville, IL 62221

Polar Plumbing, Heating & Air Conditioning provides a range of plumbing and HVAC services in St Louis, MO. Their offerings include water heater repair and installation, sump pump and sewer line repair, leak detection, gas line installation, toilet repair, and garbage disposal repair. The company is known for handling emergency situations promptly, such as same-day water heater repairs and 24/7 furnace service during cold snaps. They also perform comprehensive HVAC system installations and maintenance. Polar Plumbing has a reputation for thorough and professional work, with technicians who explain repairs clearly and maintain clean workspaces.

5.0

200 Reviews

Classic Aire Care

1276 N Warson Rd, St. Louis, MO 63132

Classic Aire Care is a plumbing and HVAC provider serving St Louis, MO, with a focus on residential and commercial services. They offer water heater repair and installation, sump pump and sewer line repair, gas line installation, and toilet repair. The company has been serving the Greater St. Louis area since 1926, providing expertise backed by decades of experience. Classic Aire Care also offers 24/7 emergency service to address urgent plumbing and HVAC needs promptly.

4.9

4.7k Reviews

Hero Handyman Pro

st louis

Hero Handyman Pro offers professional home repair and remodeling services in St Louis, MO, and the surrounding Metro East Illinois communities. Their services include drywall repair, door installation, bathroom and kitchen remodeling, carpentry, electrical work, and plumbing such as faucet and toilet repair. With over 35 years of experience, they provide skilled craftsmanship and a wide range of home improvement solutions.

4.9

238 Reviews

See more providers in St Louis, MO

Common Toilet Problems in St. Louis Homes

St. Louis's historic charm often comes with aging plumbing infrastructure, which can contribute to specific and recurring toilet troubles. Understanding these common issues is the first step toward a proper fix.

• A Running Toilet and High Water Bills: This is one of the most frequent complaints and a silent budget drainer. It's typically caused by a worn flapper that no longer seals, a faulty fill valve that doesn't shut off, or a damaged flush valve. In areas with hard water, mineral buildup can accelerate the wear on these internal parts, making this a particularly common issue in the region ^{1 2}.
• Persistent Clogs: While a plunger can handle minor blockages, frequent or severe clogs often point to deeper problems. In older St. Louis homes with cast iron or galvanized pipes, narrow diameters and corrosion can trap waste more easily. The use of "flushable" wipes, which don't break down like toilet paper, is a major culprit for blockages that require professional augering to clear ^{3 4}.
• Leaking at the Base: Water pooling around the toilet's base signals a broken seal. This is almost always due to a failed wax ring, which creates a watertight connection between the toilet and the sewer flange. If ignored, this leak can damage your subfloor and ceiling below ^{5 2}.
• A Wobbling or Loose Toilet: A toilet should be solidly anchored to the floor. If it rocks or feels loose, it indicates that the closet bolts are broken or the flange itself-the piece that connects the toilet to the drainpipe-is cracked, corroded, or loose. This is a critical repair to prevent leaks and potential toilet detachment ⁶.
• Cracked Porcelain or Outdated Fixtures: Visible cracks in the bowl or tank can lead to leaks and are a sign for immediate replacement. Many older homes also have original toilets that are inefficient, using 3.5 to 7 gallons per flush compared to modern 1.28-gallon models. Replacing an old fixture is both a practical repair and a water-saving upgrade ⁴.

Professional Repair and Replacement Services

When a DIY fix isn't enough or the problem is complex, local plumbing professionals offer a range of services to get your toilet back in working order.

• Toilet Rebuild (Overhaul): This involves replacing all the internal working parts-the fill valve, flush valve, flapper, and associated hardware. It's a comprehensive solution for a toilet that runs constantly, has weak flushes, or has multiple failing components, effectively giving an otherwise sound fixture a new lease on life ^{1 5}.
• Wax Ring and Flange Repair: To fix a leak at the base, a plumber must remove the toilet. They will replace the wax ring and inspect the underlying flange. In many St. Louis homes, especially older ones, the flange may be rusted (if metal) or broken (if plastic), requiring reinforcement or complete replacement with a repair kit to ensure a stable, leak-free base ^{3 7}.
• Professional Snaking and Augering: For tough clogs that resist a plunger, plumbers use motorized drain augers (snakes) and high-pressure water jetters. These tools can break up or retrieve blockages deep in the drain line that are inaccessible to consumer-grade equipment ³.
• Supply Line and Valve Replacement: The flexible hose that brings water to your toilet can degrade over time. Plumbers often replace old rubber or plastic lines with more durable stainless steel braided supply lines and can also upgrade the old shut-off valve for better reliability and easier future maintenance ^{7 8}.

Materials and Components for Toilet Work

The right parts are crucial for a lasting repair or installation. Professionals typically use quality materials designed for durability.

• Wax Seals: The standard is a wax ring, often now paired with a urethane or neoprene sleeve for a better seal and easier future removal. The correct thickness is chosen based on the toilet and floor setup ⁹.
• Repair Kits: These include brand-name components like Fluidmaster fill valves and flappers designed to fit most toilet models. Kits provide all the necessary parts for a standard rebuild ^{1 10}.
• Hardware: Stainless steel toilet bolts and flange repair kits are preferred because they resist the rust and corrosion that commonly affect the original hardware in humid bathroom environments ⁷.
• Supply Lines: As mentioned, stainless steel braided lines are the professional standard for new installations and replacements due to their strength and burst resistance ⁸.
• New Toilets: When replacing a fixture, high-efficiency models that use 1.28 gallons per flush (GPF) are standard. Options include elongated bowls for comfort, comfort-height (chair-height) models, and designs with powerful flush technology to prevent clogs ^{10 11}.

Understanding Costs in St. Louis

The cost for toilet services in St. Louis varies based on the job's complexity, the parts required, and whether it's a standard service call or an emergency. The city's older infrastructure can sometimes add complexity to what seems like a straightforward job ^{12 13}.

• Minor Repairs: Replacing a flapper, handle, or chain typically ranges from $50 to $150^{6 14}.
• Standard Repairs: A general toilet repair, such as fixing a running toilet by replacing internal components or addressing a minor leak, often falls between $125 and $300^{1 15}.
• Toilet Replacement (Labor): The labor cost to remove an old toilet and install a new one generally ranges from $130 to $250, assuming standard conditions ^{16 17}.
• Complete Toilet Replacement (Parts & Labor): The total project cost for a new, standard-efficiency toilet including the unit itself and professional installation typically ranges from $300 to $800+. The final price depends heavily on the toilet model selected and any unforeseen complications with the existing plumbing ^{18 19 11}.
• Complex or Emergency Repairs: Clearing a severe main line clog related to the toilet or performing an after-hours repair for a leaking or overflowing fixture can cost $300 to $600 or more^{14 17}.

Note: These are estimated price ranges based on 2025-2026 data. Your final cost can vary based on the specific contractor, your location within the city or county, the time of service, and the exact scope of work required ^{12 13}.

The Impact of Local Factors

St. Louis-specific conditions can influence your toilet's health and the repair process. The prevalence of hard water in the area leads to mineral scale buildup, which can degrade rubber flappers and valve seals faster than in softer water areas ²⁰. Furthermore, many homes in historic neighborhoods have plumbing systems that are decades old. Accessing and repairing connections in these older systems-such as dealing with rusted bolts, lead bends, or cracked cast-iron flanges-often requires specialized expertise and can extend the time and cost of a project ^{4 21}. Being aware of these local challenges helps set realistic expectations when consulting with a service professional.

Frequently asked questions

Sources