Top Toilet Repair & Replacement Contractors in Boston, Massachusetts Ranked

Dealing with a malfunctioning toilet is a common and urgent household issue in Boston. Whether it's a persistent clog, a constant running sound, or a leak at the base, a faulty toilet can waste water, cause damage, and disrupt your daily routine. Professional toilet repair and replacement services ensure these problems are diagnosed accurately and resolved with the right parts and expertise. This guide will help you understand common toilet issues, typical solutions, and what to expect when seeking professional help for your bathroom fixture in the Boston area.

Rooterman

boston

Rooterman is a sewer and drain service provider based in Boston, MA, offering residential and commercial plumbing solutions. Established in 1970, the company specializes in sewer line repair, drain cleaning, leak detection, toilet repair, and sewer camera inspections. Rooterman also provides certified Title V septic system inspections and offers same-day service for most non-emergency calls. With over 50 years of experience, Rooterman serves the Greater Boston area and surrounding communities, focusing on maintaining sewer and drain systems to protect homes and businesses.

5.0

354 Reviews

Yellow Dog Plumbing, Heating & Cooling

19 Kearney Rd, Needham, MA 02494

Yellow Dog Plumbing, Heating & Cooling is a plumbing and HVAC company based near Boston, MA, serving Newton and surrounding areas. They offer a range of services including water heater repair and installation, water softener installation, leak detection, and toilet repair. The company emphasizes technical expertise combined with attentive customer care and provides same-day service when possible. They work with various brands and handle both residential and light commercial projects. Yellow Dog Plumbing, Heating & Cooling also offers 24/7 live answering and online scheduling to support customer needs around the clock.

5.0

241 Reviews

AJM Plumbing And Heating LLC

45 Exchange St, Rockland, MA 02370

AJM Plumbing And Heating LLC is a plumbing and heating service provider based near Boston, MA. They offer water heater installation, repair, and maintenance for both tank and tankless systems, along with leak detection, repiping, gas line installation, and toilet repair. The company installs high-efficiency heating systems and provides warranties on parts and labor, with tankless water heaters qualifying for Mass Save rebates. AJM Plumbing also handles gas appliance connections and plumbing winterization to protect systems from harsh New England winters. They serve a wide area including Rockland, Hull, Quincy, and other nearby communities.

5.0

194 Reviews

Plumbing Solutions

5 Business St, Dedham, MA 02026

Plumbing Solutions is a plumbing service provider located in Boston, MA, with over 20 years of experience. They specialize in drain cleaning, gas line installation, and toilet repair, serving the South Suburban and Metro West Boston areas. The company focuses on service, repair, and remodeling, emphasizing punctuality, cleanliness, and client satisfaction. Their capabilities include handling water and steam boilers, radiant heat systems, and gas appliance installations.

4.9

1.1k Reviews

Vaughan Plumbing & Heating, LLC

boston

Vaughan Plumbing & Heating, LLC has been serving residential plumbing and heating needs in Boston, MA since 2008. The company addresses a wide range of services including water heater repair and installation, drain cleaning, leak detection, repiping, gas line installation, and toilet repair. They specialize in handling the unique plumbing challenges of Boston's older homes and harsh winters, offering expertise in winterization and emergency repairs. Vaughan Plumbing & Heating provides same-day or next-day emergency services and emphasizes clear communication and upfront pricing to keep customers informed throughout the process.

4.9

769 Reviews

See more providers in Boston, MA

Common Toilet Problems in Boston Homes

Boston residents often face a few recurring toilet troubles. Understanding the symptoms can help you describe the issue more clearly to a professional.

• Clogs: The most frequent complaint, a clog can often be cleared with a plunger. For more stubborn blockages deeper in the drain, a toilet auger or snake is the proper tool. It's generally advised to avoid chemical drain cleaners, as they can damage porcelain and pipes ^{1 2}.
• Running Water or Phantom Flushes: If your toilet sounds like it's constantly refilling or occasionally runs by itself, the culprit is usually a worn-out flapper valve or a faulty fill valve inside the tank. This is a common repair that fixes water waste ¹.
• Leaks at the Base: Water pooling around the toilet's base often indicates a failed wax ring seal or loose flange bolts. This repair requires removing the toilet to replace the seal, which is crucial to prevent water damage to your subfloor ¹.
• Weak Flush: A toilet that doesn't flush with enough force may have an issue with the water level in the tank, an improperly adjusted lift chain, or a problem with the flush valve itself ².

Repair vs. Replacement: Making the Right Choice

When your toilet acts up, the first decision is whether to fix the existing fixture or install a new one.

When Repair is the Best Option

Many toilet malfunctions are resolved with relatively simple repairs. Common fixes include replacing internal components like the flapper, fill valve, or flush valve assembly. These parts are inexpensive, and the labor, while requiring skill, is often straightforward for a professional. If your toilet is otherwise in good condition-no cracks in the porcelain, a style you like, and it flushes well when working-repair is typically the most cost-effective path. The total cost for common repairs like fixing a running toilet or replacing a flapper in Boston typically ranges from $100 to $350+, including parts and labor ^{3 4}.

Signs You Need a Full Toilet Replacement

Sometimes, installing a new commode is the wiser long-term investment. Consider replacement if:

• The toilet is cracked or has significant chips in the porcelain.
• It's an older, inefficient model that uses excessive water per flush (e.g., pre-1994 models using 3.5+ gallons).
• You experience frequent clogs or performance issues that aren't solved by standard repairs.
• You're renovating your bathroom and want to update the style or functionality.
• The toilet is damaged at the base or the flange is broken, making a secure re-installation difficult.

Understanding Costs for Toilet Services in Boston

Labor and material costs in the Boston metro area are generally higher than the national average, which is reflected in plumbing services ^{3 5}. Here's a breakdown of what you might expect.

Cost of Toilet Repairs

For a standard repair job, such as fixing a running toilet by replacing the fill valve and flapper, you can expect to pay between $100 and $350 or more ^{3 4}. This includes the service call, parts, and labor. Most plumbers charge a diagnostic or call-out fee just to assess the problem, which in Massachusetts can be around $100 or more ⁶. For more complex issues like reseating a toilet with a new wax ring or repairing a leaky supply line, the cost will be on the higher end of that scale.

Cost of Toilet Replacement

The total price for a new toilet installation has two main components: the fixture itself and the labor to install it.

• Toilet Fixture Cost: You can purchase a basic, efficient two-piece toilet for between $80 and $200+. One-piece, comfort-height (ADA-compliant), or designer models can range from $180 to $450 or more ^{1 7 8}.
• Labor Cost for Installation: If you provide the toilet, a plumber's labor to remove the old unit and install the new one typically ranges from about $190 to $400+ in Boston, often representing 1-2 hours of work ^{7 9 10}. This cost can increase if there are complications like corroded bolts, a damaged floor flange, or the need to modify plumbing connections.

Therefore, a total toilet replacement project (including a mid-range toilet and professional installation) in Boston often falls within the $300 to $800+ range ^{3 5}. Costs can climb higher for premium fixtures, complex access in older homes, or if additional plumbing work is required.

Special Considerations for Boston's Older Homes

Boston's historic housing stock presents unique challenges for plumbing work, including toilet services. In many older homes, bathrooms are in tight spaces, making access difficult. Outdated pipes, such as galvanized steel supply lines or cast iron drains, may require special attention or upgrading during a replacement project. A plumber might need to replace old shut-off valves or transition to modern materials like PEX for supply lines ^{3 8}. These factors can add time and complexity to the job, which is often reflected in the final labor cost.

Choosing the Right Toilet for Your Home

If you're replacing your fixture, you have several options:

• Two-Piece: The most common and affordable style, with a separate tank and bowl.
• One-Piece: Easier to clean with a seamless design, often at a higher price point.
• Comfort Height/ADA Compliant: These toilets are taller (similar to a chair height), making sitting down and standing up easier.
• Wall-Hung: Mounted to the wall with the tank concealed inside it. This requires significant in-wall framing and plumbing work but offers a sleek, modern look and easy floor cleaning.
• Water Efficiency: Look for WaterSense-labeled models, which use 1.28 gallons per flush or less and can significantly reduce your water bill.

The Professional Service Process

When you contact a professional for toilet repair or installation, a typical service call involves:

1. Diagnosis: The plumber will inspect the toilet, identify the root cause of the problem, and discuss options with you.
2. Estimate: You'll receive a clear estimate for the repair or replacement, including parts and labor.
3. Execution: For repairs, the technician will fix or replace the faulty components. For a replacement, they will disconnect and remove the old toilet, prepare the flange and supply line, set the new wax ring, place the new toilet, bolt it down securely, and reconnect the water supply.
4. Testing and Clean-up: The plumber will test for leaks, ensure a proper flush, and clean the work area.

Frequently asked questions

Sources