Best Toilet Repair & Replacement Contractors in Indiana Ranked

A malfunctioning toilet is more than an inconvenience; it's a disruption to your daily routine and can lead to wasted water, higher bills, and potential water damage. Whether you're dealing with a constant running sound, a persistent clog, or a leak at the base, understanding your options for toilet repair or replacement is key to restoring function and efficiency in your Indiana home. This guide provides clear, practical information on common toilet problems, DIY fixes, when to call a professional, and how to find qualified local plumbing experts to handle the job.

Roto-Rooter Plumbing & Water Cleanup

18 E Main St Ste 230, Greenfield, IN 46140

Roto-Rooter Plumbing & Water Cleanup provides a wide range of plumbing services in Indianapolis, IN, including sewer and drain cleaning, water heater repair and installation, sump pump services, and leak detection. They specialize in both residential and commercial plumbing, offering advanced solutions such as hydro jetting and trenchless sewer repair to address complex plumbing issues. Established in 1935, Roto-Rooter has a long history of innovation and expertise in plumbing, and they offer 24/7 emergency services to handle urgent plumbing problems at any time.

5.0

919 Reviews

Home Heroes Plumbing Heating & Air

7768 Kane Ct, Fishers, IN 46038

Home Heroes Plumbing Heating & Air is a locally owned plumbing, heating, and air conditioning service provider based in Fishers, Indiana. Serving Indianapolis, IN, and surrounding areas, they offer a range of services including water heater repair and installation, tankless water heater services, water softener installation, sump pump repair, drain cleaning, leak detection, gas line installation, and toilet repair. The company specializes in handling plumbing emergencies during business hours and provides expert solutions such as Rheem water heater installations, including tankless models. With over a decade of experience, Home Heroes Plumbing Heating & Air is committed to delivering reliable service tailored to customer needs.

5.0

808 Reviews

Flow-Tech Plumbing & Heating, Inc.

8131 N Clinton St, Fort Wayne, IN 46825

Flow-Tech Plumbing & Heating, Inc. has been serving Fort Wayne, IN, and surrounding areas since 1991. They provide a wide range of plumbing and HVAC services for both residential and commercial properties, including water softener installation, sump pump repair, drain cleaning, gas line installation, toilet repair, and garbage disposal repair. Their team is skilled in handling backflow prevention, bathroom and kitchen plumbing, and advanced systems like water purifiers and reverse osmosis. Flow-Tech also offers 24/7 emergency services to address urgent plumbing and HVAC needs promptly. With decades of experience, they bring local expertise to keep homes and businesses comfortable and safe year-round.

5.0

427 Reviews

Cornwell Plumbing

5724 N Green St 2nd Floor, Brownsburg, IN 46112

Cornwell Plumbing is a family-owned plumbing company serving Indianapolis, IN, and surrounding areas including Brownsburg, Pittsboro, and Hendricks County. Established in 1989, they offer a wide range of plumbing services such as sewer camera inspections, water heater repair and installation, water softener installation, sump pump and sewage pump repair, drain cleaning, leak detection, repiping, toilet and garbage disposal repair. Their expertise includes using advanced tools like sewer cameras to diagnose pipe issues accurately. Cornwell Plumbing provides emergency plumbing services when available and focuses on personalized, honest service for both residential and commercial clients.

5.0

267 Reviews

Mr. Plumber by Metzler & Hallam

1033 3rd Ave SW Suite 205, Carmel, IN 46032

Mr. Plumber by Metzler & Hallam is a licensed plumbing service provider based in Indianapolis, IN, offering a wide range of plumbing solutions. Their services include sewer camera inspection, water heater repair, water softener installation, sump pump repair, sewer line repair with trenchless technology, leak detection, gas line installation, toilet and garbage disposal repair, among others. They utilize advanced tools such as camera snaking systems and infrared cameras to diagnose plumbing issues efficiently. The company emphasizes trenchless sewer line repair methods like pipe bursting and relining to minimize property disruption. Mr. Plumber provides 24/7 emergency service, ensuring assistance is available whenever needed.

4.9

4.6k Reviews

See more providers in Indiana

Common Toilet Problems in Indiana Homes

Indiana homeowners frequently encounter a handful of specific toilet issues. Recognizing the symptoms can help you diagnose the problem and decide on the next steps.

• Running Toilet: This is one of the most common complaints and a major source of water waste. It's often caused by a worn flapper that no longer seals properly or an incorrectly adjusted fill valve ¹. You'll hear water constantly trickling into the bowl.
• Clogged Toilet: Frequent clogs can result from using too much toilet paper, flushing non-flushable items, or, in more severe cases, root intrusion into the main sewer line ^{1 2}. A plunger can often resolve minor blockages.
• Leaking at the Base: Water pooling around your toilet's base signals a compromised wax ring seal or loose closet bolts ^{1 3}. This leak can damage your subfloor and should be addressed promptly.
• Weak or Incomplete Flush: If your toilet doesn't clear the bowl effectively, the cause could be clogged rim jets, low water level in the tank, or issues with the fill valve ⁴.
• Gurgling Noises: Unusual gurgling sounds from the toilet or other drains often point to venting issues or problems deeper in the drain line, requiring professional diagnosis ⁵.

DIY Toilet Repair: What You Can Safely Handle

For handy homeowners, some toilet repairs are straightforward. Always start by shutting off the water supply using the valve located on the wall behind the toilet.

1. Diagnose the Issue: Remove the tank lid. Check if the water level is about an inch below the overflow tube. Listen for leaks and inspect the flapper seal.
2. Replace Common Parts: Components like the flapper, fill valve, and handle are widely available at any Indiana hardware store and are designed for DIY replacement ^{6 7}. Kits typically cost between $10 and $30 ^{8 3}.
3. Check for Base Leaks: Gently rock the toilet. If it moves, the closet bolts may be loose. Carefully tighten them, but avoid overtightening, which can crack the porcelain ^{1 4}.

If these steps don't resolve the issue, or if you are dealing with a leak at the base, it's time to call a professional.

When to Call a Professional Plumber

While some fixes are simple, certain situations demand a pro's expertise to prevent costly water damage or improper installation.

• Replacing the Wax Ring: This seal between the toilet and the floor drain is critical. Improper installation will lead to persistent leaks and floor rot. This job is best left to professionals ¹.
• Replacing the Flange: The closet flange is the pipe fitting that secures the toilet to the floor. If it's cracked or broken, it requires specialized repair.
• Persistent Clogs or Gurgling: These symptoms can indicate a blockage or vent problem deep in your home's plumbing system that requires professional snaking or camera inspection ^{5 2}.
• Installing a New Toilet: Proper installation ensures a leak-free seal, stable mounting, and correct connection to the water supply. A professional ensures it's done right the first time.

Cost of Toilet Repair vs. Replacement in Indiana

Understanding the costs involved can help you make a budget-conscious decision. Prices can vary based on the specific problem, toilet model, and labor rates in your area of Indiana.

• DIY Repair (Parts Only): Replacing a flapper or fill valve yourself typically costs between $10 and $50 for the parts ^{6 9}.
• Professional Repair: For common issues like a running or leaking toilet, hiring a plumber in Indiana generally costs between $150 and $400, which includes both labor and parts ^{6 10 11}.
• Toilet Replacement Cost:
  • Fixture Only: A new, standard to high-efficiency toilet ranges from $100 to over $300^{8 3}.
  • DIY Installation: If you install it yourself, total cost is typically $225 to $500+ (fixture plus supplies) ¹².
  • Professional Installation: Having a plumber handle the full replacement, including removal of the old unit, typically runs between $900 and $2,200 in total ^{6 9}.

Repair or Replace? Making the Right Choice

How do you decide whether to fix your old toilet or invest in a new one? Consider these guidelines:

Opt for Repair If:

• The toilet is relatively new (less than 10 years old).
• The problem is isolated to an inexpensive, easy-to-replace part like the flapper, fill valve, or handle ¹.
• The porcelain is in good condition with no cracks.

Consider Replacement If:

• The porcelain bowl or tank is cracked.
• You are facing constant repairs on an older unit.
• The toilet is an outdated, inefficient model (often 15+ years old). Replacing it with a modern, water-saving toilet can reduce your water usage and save money on your utility bills over time ^{8 13}.

Choosing a High-Efficiency Toilet

If replacement is the right choice, consider upgrading to a WaterSense-labeled model. These toilets use 1.28 gallons per flush or less, compared to older models that may use 3.5 to 7 gallons. For an Indiana household, this upgrade can lead to significant annual water savings ⁸.

Frequently asked questions

Sources