Best Toilet Repair & Replacement Contractors in Idaho Ranked

A functioning toilet is essential for any Idaho home, but issues like leaks, clogs, and constant running are common frustrations. Timely toilet repair or replacement can prevent water damage, conserve a precious resource, and restore daily convenience. This guide provides Idaho homeowners with clear information on common problems, repair versus replacement decisions, and local cost insights to help you make informed choices and connect with qualified professionals for your project.

Proficient Plumbing Service

75 W Taylor Ave #200, Meridian, ID 83642

Proficient Plumbing Service is a locally owned plumbing company serving Boise, ID, and the surrounding Treasure Valley communities. They offer a wide range of plumbing services including water heater repair and installation, water softener installation, sump pump repair, drain cleaning, leak detection, repiping, gas line installation, toilet repair, and garbage disposal repair. Their fully stocked plumbing trucks provide service to Boise, Meridian, Eagle, Nampa, and other nearby areas. Proficient Plumbing Service emphasizes attention to detail to prevent future issues and maintain customer satisfaction.

5.0

476 Reviews

Zoom Drain

601 E 44th St #4, Garden City, ID 83714

Zoom Drain is a plumbing service provider based in Boise, ID, specializing in drain and sewer cleaning, repairs, and maintenance for both residential and commercial clients. They offer services such as drain inspection, preventative maintenance, sewer line repairs, sump pump repair, and garbage disposal repair. Zoom Drain is equipped to handle various plumbing issues, including clogged drains and sewer emergencies, using advanced tools and tailored maintenance plans. Serving Boise and nearby areas like Garden City, Caldwell, and Eagle, the company has over 10 years of experience in the industry.

5.0

175 Reviews

Goodson Plumbing Services

5103 W Bethel St STE 120, Boise, ID 83706

Goodson Plumbing Services is a locally owned plumbing company based in Boise, Idaho, serving Boise and surrounding areas including Meridian, Kuna, Eagle, and Nampa. With over 20 years of experience, they provide a range of plumbing services such as water heater repair, drain cleaning, and toilet repair. The company is licensed, bonded, and insured, and their team is committed to clear communication throughout the service process. Goodson Plumbing Services has been recognized as a 2025 Nextdoor Neighborhood Favorite, reflecting strong community trust.

4.9

550 Reviews

Roto-Rooter Plumbing & Water Cleanup

2399 S Orchard St Ste 101, Boise, ID 83705

Roto-Rooter Plumbing & Water Cleanup provides a wide range of plumbing services for homes and businesses in Boise, ID. Their offerings include drain cleaning, sewer line repair using trenchless technology, water heater installation and repair, leak detection, and emergency plumbing available 24/7. The company uses advanced tools such as video camera inspections to diagnose sewer issues and offers floodwater cleanup and mold remediation services. Serving Boise and surrounding areas, Roto-Rooter combines local expertise with comprehensive plumbing solutions to address both residential and commercial needs.

4.9

512 Reviews

IdaPros Plumbing & Drains

1800 W Overland Rd Ste 380A, Boise, ID 83705

IdaPros Plumbing & Drains is a plumbing company serving Boise, ID, and the surrounding Treasure Valley area including Meridian, Caldwell, Eagle, and Star. With over 30 years of experience, they offer a range of plumbing services such as sewer camera inspections, water heater repair and installation, drain cleaning, hydro jetting, sewer line repair, and toilet repair. Their team is licensed, bonded, and insured, providing solutions from routine maintenance to emergency plumbing needs. IdaPros also offers 24/7 emergency service to address urgent plumbing issues promptly.

5.0

100 Reviews

See more providers in Idaho

Common Toilet Problems in Idaho Homes

Understanding the specific issue with your toilet is the first step toward a solution. Most residential toilet troubles fall into a few key categories, each with distinct causes and fixes.

Running Toilets (Water Wasting)

A toilet that runs continuously or cycles on and off is one of the most common and wasteful problems. It can waste hundreds of gallons of water per day, significantly impacting your utility bill ¹. The primary culprits are usually inside the tank:

• Worn Flapper: The rubber flapper that seals the flush valve opening can degrade over time, allowing water to leak from the tank into the bowl.
• Faulty Fill Valve: A malfunctioning fill valve may not shut off properly, causing the tank to overfill and water to flow into the overflow tube.
• Misadjusted Float: If the float ball or cup is set too high, it allows the tank to fill beyond the proper level, triggering a run.
• Refill Tube Issues: A disconnected or improperly positioned refill tube can siphon water into the bowl.

Leaks (At the Base or Bowl)

Water pooling around the base of your toilet is a serious issue that can damage flooring and subflooring. This is often caused by a compromised seal ².

• Failed Wax Ring: The wax ring seal between the toilet flange and the drain pipe is the most common cause of base leaks. It can dry out, crack, or become misaligned.
• Loose Tee Bolts: The bolts securing the toilet to the floor can loosen over time, breaking the seal.
• Cracked Porcelain: Though less common, a hairline crack in the toilet's base or tank can cause a persistent leak.

Clogs and Weak Flushes

A toilet that flushes poorly, drains slowly, or becomes clogged frequently disrupts household function. Causes range from simple blockages to mechanical failures ³.

• Drain Line Blockage: The most frequent cause, often from excessive toilet paper or non-flushable items.
• Low Water Level in Tank: If not enough water enters the bowl during a flush, it may lack the necessary force.
• Faulty Flush Valve or Handle: A broken handle, loose chain, or obstructed flush valve can prevent a full, proper flush.

Slow Filling Tanks

A tank that takes an unusually long time to refill after flushing is typically due to a problem with the water supply mechanism ⁴.

• Partially Closed Supply Valve: The shut-off valve on the wall behind the toilet may not be fully open.
• Clogged or Failing Fill Valve: Mineral deposits can clog the fill valve, or its internal parts may simply wear out.

DIY Repair vs. Professional Help

Some toilet repairs are well within the capability of a handy homeowner, while others benefit significantly from a professional's touch. Knowing the difference can save you time, money, and potential headaches.

When to Consider a DIY Fix

With basic tools and replacement parts readily available at local hardware stores, you can tackle several common issues ^{5 3}.

• Replacing Internal Tank Parts: Installing a new flapper, fill valve assembly, flush valve, or handle is generally straightforward. Replacement kits often cost between $10 and $30 and come with clear instructions ^{6 7}.
• Fixing a Running Toilet: Adjusting the float height, reconnecting the refill tube, or cleaning mineral deposits from the fill valve are simple first steps.
• Clearing Minor Clogs: Using a quality plunger or a small closet auger (toilet snake) can resolve many simple blockages.

When to Call a Professional Plumber

Certain situations warrant calling a licensed Idaho plumber to ensure the repair is done correctly and to prevent collateral damage ^{2 8}.

• Any Leak at the Toilet Base: Resealing a toilet by replacing the wax ring is a messy job. If not done perfectly, it will leak again and cause hidden damage. Professionals have the expertise to do it right the first time.
• Stubborn or Recurring Clogs: If a plunger and auger don't work, the blockage may be deep in your drain line, requiring professional-grade equipment.
• Replacing the Toilet Itself: Installation involves heavy lifting, proper sealing, and secure connection to water and waste lines. An improper install can lead to leaks and rocking.
• Suspected Cracks or Major Mechanical Failure: Diagnosing and fixing a cracked porcelain fixture or a complex valve issue is best left to experts.
• Lack of Time, Tools, or Confidence: If you're unsure at any point, hiring a pro is a cost-effective way to guarantee a lasting repair.

Understanding Costs for Toilet Services in Idaho

The cost for toilet repair or replacement in Idaho varies based on the problem's complexity, the parts required, and the plumber's labor rates. Here's a breakdown of what you can expect.

Cost of Common Repairs

Professional repair costs typically include a service call fee, hourly labor, and the price of parts. In Idaho, plumber hourly rates generally range from $65 to $75 per hour plus parts ^{6 9}.

• Internal Tank Repair (e.g., flapper, fill valve): $100 - $200. This is often a relatively quick fix for a pro ².
• Wax Ring Replacement: $50 - $200. The wide range depends on accessibility and whether any floor damage needs addressing ^{1 8}.
• Unclogging a Toilet: $100 - $250, depending on the severity and location of the blockage.
• General Repair (any issue): $100 - $400+. More complex issues like replacing a flush valve or fixing a supply line will be on the higher end ^{6 2}.

Cost of Toilet Replacement

Replacing an old toilet with a new one involves the cost of the fixture plus installation labor.

• New Toilet Fixture: Homeowners can expect to pay between $100 and $400+ for a standard, efficient model at local retailers. Prices increase for features like elongated bowls, comfort height, or dual-flush mechanisms ^{7 5}.
• Professional Installation (Labor): If you purchase the toilet separately, typical installation labor in Idaho ranges from approximately $135 to $150 ^{6 9}.
• Total Replacement Project Cost: For a full replacement provided by a plumber (including a mid-range toilet), total costs often fall between $400 and $700+ ⁶.

Repair or Replace? Making the Right Choice

Deciding whether to fix your existing toilet or invest in a new one depends on several factors.

When Repair is the Best Option

• The Toilet is Relatively New: For toilets less than 10-15 years old, repairs are usually cost-effective.
• The Problem is Minor: Isolated issues like a worn flapper, faulty fill valve, or loose handle are inexpensive to fix.
• You Like Your Current Fixture: If the toilet is a special color, style, or fits a unique space, repair preserves it.

When Replacement Makes More Sense

• The Toilet is Old and Inefficient: Toilets manufactured before 1994 use 3.5 to 7 gallons per flush. Replacing it with a 1.28 GPF WaterSense model can save thousands of gallons of water annually ¹⁰.
• Frequent Repairs: If you're constantly fixing different issues, a new toilet offers reliability and peace of mind.
• Visible Cracks: Any crack in the porcelain is a failure point and a sanitation risk; replacement is necessary.
• Cost of Repair Approaches Replacement: If the repair quote is half or more of the cost of a new, efficient toilet installed, replacement is often the better long-term value ⁵.
• Desired Upgrade: Modern toilets offer better performance, easier cleaning features, and improved comfort.

Finding Parts and Professional Services

For DIY repairs, parts like flappers, fill valves, and bolts are widely available at home improvement centers like Lowe's and Home Depot, as well as local plumbing supply stores across Idaho ³. When your project requires a professional, it's important to choose a licensed, insured plumber with positive local references. They can provide accurate diagnoses, warranties on their work, and ensure your toilet system functions correctly and efficiently.

Frequently asked questions

Sources