Best Water Heater Repair Companies in Minnesota Ranked

A broken water heater is more than an inconvenience in Minnesota; it's a disruption to daily life, especially during our cold winters. Understanding your options for water heater repair is essential for restoring hot water quickly, safely, and cost-effectively. This guide explains the key differences between gas and electric unit repairs, common problems, typical costs in Minnesota, and how to decide between fixing your current unit or investing in a replacement. Use the information here to make an informed decision and connect with qualified local professionals who can diagnose and resolve your issue.

Roto-Rooter Plumbing & Water Cleanup

611 Bielenberg Dr Ste 3-114, Woodbury, MN 55125

Roto-Rooter Plumbing & Water Cleanup serves St Paul, MN, providing full-service plumbing, drain cleaning, and water cleanup for residential and commercial customers. Established in 1935, the company offers a range of services including sewer camera inspections, water heater repair and installation, sump pump repair, and emergency plumbing. They use state-of-the-art equipment and provide 24/7 emergency service with no extra charges for nights, weekends, or holidays.

5.0

533 Reviews

Water Heaters Now!

126 2nd St S, Stillwater, MN 55082

Water Heaters Now! is a specialized plumbing service in St Paul, MN, focusing exclusively on water heater repair, installation, and maintenance. They install professional-grade water heaters, including tankless models, and are recognized as one of the largest installers in the Midwest. The company offers same-day installation for tank-style water heaters when called before 2 p.m. and employs experienced technicians with over 40 years of combined expertise. Water Heaters Now! also handles permits and warranty processing to support customers throughout the ownership of their water heaters.

5.0

441 Reviews

Hurlburt Heating & Plumbing

1000 County Rd E Suite 115, Shoreview, MN 55126

Hurlburt Heating & Plumbing is a family-owned home services provider serving St Paul, MN, and surrounding areas. Since 1959, they have offered plumbing, HVAC, and electrical services, including water heater repair, water softener installation, drain cleaning, and sewer line repair. Their experienced technicians use modern tools to address a wide range of home service needs. With a long history in the region, Hurlburt combines local knowledge with comprehensive capabilities to support homeowners year-round.

5.0

438 Reviews

Good Guys Plumbing LLC

st paul

Good Guys Plumbing LLC is a family-owned plumbing company serving St Paul, MN, and nearby areas including Oakdale and Woodbury. They provide a wide range of residential plumbing services such as water heater repair and installation, sump pump repair, leak detection, gas line installation, and water softener installation. The company specializes in working with PEX, copper, and galvanized water systems and offers backflow prevention and water treatment solutions. With over a decade of experience, Good Guys Plumbing focuses on residential plumbing needs and maintaining home plumbing systems.

5.0

248 Reviews

Pronto Heating and Air Conditioning - Minneapolis

7415 Cahill Rd, Minneapolis, MN 55439

Pronto Heating and Air Conditioning - Minneapolis provides HVAC and plumbing services in Minneapolis, MN. They offer water heater repair and installation, leak detection, and gas line installation among their plumbing services. The company is a Bryant Factory Authorized Dealer with expertise in heating, cooling, and indoor air quality systems. They serve Minneapolis and nearby communities, focusing on system maintenance, repair, and installation. Pronto Heating and Air Conditioning emphasizes prompt emergency service and offers a One Day Installation and No-Stress Guarantee for upgrades and replacements.

4.9

5.4k Reviews

See more providers in Minnesota

Understanding Gas vs. Electric Water Heater Repairs

The type of water heater you have-gas or electric-fundamentally changes the repair process, complexity, and associated costs. In Minnesota, repairs for gas units are generally more complex and costly than for electric models due to the added safety components and labor requirements involved with gas lines and combustion ^{1 2 3}.

While both types can suffer from issues like inconsistent hot water or strange noises, the underlying causes and repair approaches differ significantly ⁴. For example, a lack of hot water in an electric heater often points to a failed heating element or thermostat, while in a gas unit, it could be a faulty thermocouple, gas control valve, or burner assembly. Safety is also a primary concern: gas repairs carry risks of gas leaks and carbon monoxide exposure if not handled correctly, whereas electric repairs pose a risk of electrical shock ^{5 6}.

Common Problems and Their Causes

Identifying the symptom is the first step toward a solution. Here's a breakdown of common water heater issues and their typical causes based on your unit's fuel type:

The Professional Repair Process in Minnesota

For safety and compliance with state and local codes, repairs involving gas lines, electrical connections, or plumbing should always be performed by a licensed professional ^{7 8}. A proper repair involves a systematic approach:

1. Diagnosis: A licensed technician will first inspect the entire unit. This includes verifying the gas or power supply, testing thermostats and heating elements (or burners), checking safety valves like the temperature and pressure relief (T&P) valve, and looking for signs of corrosion or sediment ^{2 9}.
2. Repair/Replacement: Using quality parts, the technician will replace the faulty component. Common repairs include swapping out a thermocouple or gas control valve on a gas unit, replacing a heating element or thermostat on an electric unit, or flushing sediment from the tank ^{10 11}.
3. Safety Checks: This is a critical step, especially for gas units. The technician will perform gas leak tests, inspect the venting system for blockages, and ensure proper combustion. For electric units, they will verify all electrical connections are secure and properly grounded ⁷.
4. Testing: Finally, the unit is restored to operation and tested to ensure it heats water reliably and maintains safe operating parameters before the job is complete.

Cost of Water Heater Repair in Minnesota

Repair costs in Minnesota tend to run about 10% higher than the national average due to labor rates and climate considerations ^{12 10}. The average cost for a typical repair is around $396, but the total can range from $90 for a very minor fix to over $750 for complex issues involving gas valves or significant leak remediation ^{12 10}.

Here's a more detailed look at common repair costs:

• Replacing a heating element (electric): $200-$300
• Replacing a thermostat: $150-$200
• Replacing a thermocouple (gas): $150
• Replacing a gas control valve (gas): $300-$500
• Tank flushing/sediment removal: $75-$250
• Minor leak repair (valves/fittings): $150-$400
• Major leak repair (if tank is salvageable): $850-$1,800 (Note: Leaks originating from the tank itself usually indicate corrosion and typically require a full replacement) ^{13 14 15 16}.

When to Repair vs. Replace Your Water Heater

Knowing when to fix an old unit and when to invest in a new one can save you money and hassle in the long run. Consider replacement if:

• The repair cost is high: A good rule of thumb is if the repair quote is more than half the cost of a new, comparable unit, replacement is often the more economical choice ¹⁷.
• The unit is old: The typical lifespan of a standard tank water heater is 8-12 years. If your unit is within or beyond this range and requires a major repair, replacement may be a wiser investment ^{18 19}.
• The tank is leaking: A leak from the tank body itself is a sign of internal corrosion and cannot be permanently repaired. Replacement is necessary ²⁰.
• You want improved efficiency: Newer models, especially high-efficiency gas, electric, or tankless water heaters, can significantly reduce your energy bills. It's worth checking for available utility rebates for high-efficiency units through the Minnesota Department of Commerce, which can offset the initial cost ^{21 22}.

A standard tank water heater replacement in Minnesota typically costs between $1,200 and $3,000 installed, depending on the unit's capacity, efficiency, and complexity of the installation ^{12 18}.

Maintaining Your Water Heater

Proactive maintenance can prevent many common problems and extend the life of your unit:

• Annual Flushing: Draining a few gallons from the tank once a year helps remove sediment buildup, which is a common cause of noise, reduced efficiency, and element damage ³.
• Anode Rod Inspection: The anode rod sacrifices itself to protect your tank from corrosion. Have it inspected every 3-5 years and replaced if heavily corroded.
• Test the T&P Valve: Lift the lever on the temperature and pressure relief valve annually to ensure it operates freely and allows water to discharge. This is a critical safety device.
• Check for Leaks: Periodically inspect the area around your water heater for any signs of moisture or dripping.

Frequently asked questions

Sources